eBay vs Whatnot: which one pays you more?
Enter one price and cost and see what you keep on eBay and Whatnot side by side. On a $50 sale (before item cost): Whatnot pays $1.82 more.
You keep $1.82 more on Whatnot
than on eBay.
eBay
Customize →$21.32
net profit
- Fees
- $7.68
- Margin
- 42.6%
- ROI
- 142.2%
- Net profit$21.32
- Marketplace fees$7.68
- Item cost$15.00
- Shipping & other$6.00
Whatnot
Customize →$23.15
net profit
- Fees
- $5.85
- Margin
- 46.3%
- ROI
- 154.3%
- Net profit$23.15
- Marketplace fees$5.85
- Item cost$15.00
- Shipping & other$6.00
Payout by price tier
Payout after marketplace fees, before item cost and shipping. The better payout is highlighted.
| Sale price | eBay fees | eBay payout | Whatnot fees | Whatnot payout | Better payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $15 | $2.58 | $12.42 | $1.97 | $13.03 | Whatnot by $0.62 |
| $30 | $4.77 | $25.23 | $3.63 | $26.37 | Whatnot by $1.13 |
| $50 | $7.68 | $42.32 | $5.85 | $44.15 | Whatnot by $1.82 |
| $100 | $14.95 | $85.05 | $11.40 | $88.60 | Whatnot by $3.55 |
| $250 | $36.78 | $213.22 | $28.06 | $221.94 | Whatnot by $8.72 |
| $500 | $73.16 | $426.84 | $55.82 | $444.19 | Whatnot by $17.35 |
Crossover points: Whatnot pays more at every price from $5 to $1,000, so there is no crossover to plan around.
When to choose eBay vs Whatnot
Choose eBay when…
- You want the largest buyer pool for used, vintage or niche items
- You sell high-value items where a percentage fee is acceptable and demand is proven
- You want auctions or Best Offer to discover price
Fees at a glance
- 13.6% (12.7% with a Store) final value fee (most categories)
- 15.3% (same with a Store) books, music, movies
- 6.7% (same with a Store) guitars and basses
Choose Whatnot when…
- You sell collectibles, cards, sneakers or streetwear through live shows
- You benefit from impulse buying and auction-style price discovery
- You can run frequent shows to build a following
Fees at a glance
- 8% (4% Coins and Money) commission
- 2.9% + $0.30 payment processing
eBay vs Whatnot FAQs
Is eBay or Whatnot cheaper for a $50 sale?
With no shipping and no item cost, eBay leaves $42.32 and Whatnot leaves $44.15 on a $50 sale. Whatnot pays $1.82 more.
Which pays more on a $250 sale, eBay or Whatnot?
At $250, eBay leaves $213.22 and Whatnot leaves $221.94. Whatnot pays $8.72 more. Higher prices favor the platform with the lower percentage fee, because flat fees matter less.
Where do eBay and Whatnot fees cross over?
Whatnot pays more at every price from $5 to $1,000, so there is no crossover to plan around.
Does shipping change the eBay vs Whatnot result?
It can. On a $50 sale where the buyer pays $8 shipping and your label costs $8, eBay leaves $41.16 and Whatnot leaves $43.90. Whatnot pays $2.74 more. Platforms that charge fees on shipping and tax, such as eBay, take a bigger cut when the buyer pays shipping. Poshmark uses a prepaid label, so shipping inputs do not apply there.